Narrow focus, yes-no answers and tags
A yes-no question is a query about polarity (see
3.14
). A direct answer to a yes-no question involves narrow focus on polarity and the words that indicates it.
To give a direct answer, we can say yes or no (or use a synonymous adverb or adverbial phrase, such as sure, definitely or no way). The nucleus goes on this word or phrase:
〉 Have you finished?
》 'Yes
》 'Definitely
》 Oh 'sure
》 'No.
》 ▸Not 'really.
The word yes or no (or its equivalent) may be followed by a short sentence fragment (or indeed a longer sentence) involving a verb. Less commonly, we use the sentence fragment without a yes or no. It, too, bears a nuclear accent. In a sentence or sentence fragment used in this way, it is the operator(= auxiliary or modal verb) that shows whether the sentence is positive (yes) or negative (no). The focus is on the polarity, so we put the nucleus on the verb.
》 'Yes
》 'Definitely
》 Oh 'sure
》 'No.
》 ▸Not 'really.
〉 Have you finished?
》 'Yes, | I 'have.
》 'Yes, | I 'have finished.
》 I 'have.
》 'No, | I 'haven't.
》 'No, | I 'haven't finished
It is also possible to deaccent the initial yes or no:
》 'Yes, | I 'have.
》 'Yes, | I 'have finished.
》 I 'have.
》 'No, | I 'haven't.
》 'No, | I 'haven't finished
〉 Have you finished?
》 Yes I 'have.
》 No I 'haven't
Although the word not is accentable, the n't of a contracted form is not: instead, the accent goes on the stressed syllable of the word containing n't:
》 Yes I 'have.
》 No I 'haven't
〉 Is that a firearm?
》 'No, | it's 'not.
》 'No, | it 'isn't.
〉 Can she manage Wednesday?
》 'No, | She 'can't.
Notice the difference between narrow focus on polarity in answer to a yes-no question and narrow focus on a noun phrase in answer to a wh question:
》 'No, | it's 'not.
》 'No, | it 'isn't.
〉 Can she manage Wednesday?
》 'No, | She 'can't.
〉 Is Peter coming?
》 Yes, | he 'is.
》 Yes, Peter 'is coming.
Who's coming?
》 'Peter is.
》 'Peter's coming.
There are various other elliptical constructions which likewise have narrow focus on the word that indicates polarity:
》 Yes, | he 'is.
》 Yes, Peter 'is coming.
Who's coming?
》 'Peter is.
》 'Peter's coming.
〉 D'you think they'll appeal?
》 I'm afraid they 'might.
〉 Is she going to reply?
》 I ▸don't think she 'will.
〉Are you coming out with us?
》 I'm a▸fraid 'not
We also get a nucleus on the polarity word in tag-like questions consisting of a verb plus a pronoun. These, too, involve narrow focus on polarity:
》 I'm afraid they 'might.
〉 Is she going to reply?
》 I ▸don't think she 'will.
〉Are you coming out with us?
》 I'm a▸fraid 'not
〉 We're nearly ready.
》 'Are you?
〉 They haven't taken their vouchers.
》 Haven't they?
〉 You're quite wrong, you know.
》 'Am I?
And the same applies to tag questions if (as is usually the case) they have their own IP:
》 'Are you?
〉 They haven't taken their vouchers.
》 Haven't they?
〉 You're quite wrong, you know.
》 'Am I?
It's a ▸beautiful 'day, | 'isn't it?
We could ▸go to 'Chichester, | 'couldn't we?
They've for▸gotten all a'bout it, | 'haven't they?
▸Wayne didn't 'call, | 'did he?
We could ▸go to 'Chichester, | 'couldn't we?
They've for▸gotten all a'bout it, | 'haven't they?
▸Wayne didn't 'call, | 'did he?